Melbourne offers a taste of some of the world’s greatest cities. Here’s how to experience the best of New York City, right here in downtown Melbourne.

Pizza by the slice

New York is fuelled by pizza. Grabbing a thin-based, shockingly large slice on the go is a quintessential experience from the Bronx all the way to Staten Island. For a taste of NY-pie, check out the classics at Pizza Pizza Pizza in Meyers Place (there’s also a hidden bar at the back, perfect for dodging the midtown crowds). Dip down Flinders Lane and you can grab a slice of Sal’s Authentic New York Pizza. Complain about the tourists for added authenticity.

Pepperoni pizza and hawaiian pizza from Pizza pizza pizza
Pizza by the slice at Pizza Pizza Pizza

Diners and American BBQ

If you want to imagine you’re sinking your teeth into the pastrami-on-rye or the outrageous beef brisket sandwich at Katz’s, head to Fancy Hank’s on Bourke Street. Their pastrami and smoky brisket will transport you straight to East Houston Street. Late-night burger joint Butchers Diner puts on an impeccable spread too. Visit on Thursdays for a house made wagyu pastrami Rueben, served with all the trimmings.

Find the best bagel shops

Step down into Bowery to Williamsburg and order up a teetering turkey club. Grab a side of mac and cheese (served in NY style with a pickle and a pretzel), with a Melbourne-grade latte served in kitsch diner design cups. Or try Schmucks Bagels. The fully loaded 'luv you lox' bagel with smoked salmon, cream cheese, pickled red onions and cress is New York in a bite.

Someone holding a sliced bagel filled with chicken and salad.
Bowery to Williamsburg

Order up New York cheesecake

Brunetti offers an epic cake collection, and the New York cheesecake is one of our all time faves. The decadent, baked cream cheese filling sits atop a buttery biscuit base. Served with seasonal fruit for a refreshing touch of sweetness. Pop in for a slice or grab a whole one to go, we ain't judging.

Find flea market fashion and Fifth Avenue style

Head to Saturdays NYC in QV for gorgeous, minimalist clothing and lifestyle products. At Emporium, you can pick up an elegant handbag or wallet from Kate Spade New York. Rag & Bone on Elizabeth Street is the Melbourne outpost of this coveted New York clothing brand. If vintage is your jam, pick through the racks of old-school thrift-store finds at American Rag. They source their garments from the US, so you just might score a Brooklyn flea market find in your own backyard.

American Rag logo t-shirt on a mannequin
American Rag

Catch a Broadway show

Step inside Her Majesty’s Theatre and emerge in the streets of 18th century New York. Hamilton is the new cult favourite musical with music by Lin-Manuel Miranda. The award winning show delves into American history through the story of Alexander Hamilton. Already seen it? After making it's debut in New York four years ago, Harry Potter and the Cursed Child has taken up residence in Melbourne's own Princess Theatre. The magical show recently relaunched as a refreshed one night version.

More New York style bars and diners to try

Bar Sabbatico

Tiny bar serving cocktail tasting menus.

Pepe's Italian & Liquor

An Italian-American restaurant located in a leafy enclave of Melbourne's central business area.

Ferdydurke

Unassuming bar that feels like a New York loft, named after a 1937 Polish novel.

Bobby's Coffee

Cafe specialising in bagels and delicious coffee.

Natural History

Large bar and grill that serves up an American southern-style steakhouse menu.

Market Lane Bar

Vintage whisky bar meets New York-style supper club.

Dive Bar

A glamourous take on a New York-style dive bar with an extensive cocktail list.

Schmucks Bagels

Delicious bagels with a filling for everyone and great coffee to go with it.

Last updated on Wed 25 May 2022

Get to the city or get FOMO

We’ve got every FOMO-worthy Melbourne event and experience in one place.

Find out more

The best hidden restaurants in Melbourne

Featuring laneway eateries, secret diners and undiscovered spots.

The best wine bars in Melbourne

Find luxurious cheese plates, hidden cocktail bars and cosy date-night spots.

The ultimate guide to bottomless dining in Melbourne

Eat and drink your heart out with unlimited brunches, lunches and cocktails.

Discover more

Grand Trailer Park Taverna

Decadent burgers and lavish alcoholic milkshakes.

Melbourne's best rooftop bars

Melbourne's best rooftop bars are back open - and some are now taking bookings.

The ultimate guide to Melbourne's hidden bars

Finding Melbourne’s hidden bars can be challenging. Read our guide to find the city's top spots.

Melbourne's best cheap eats

Pizza by the slice, cheap happy hour deals and more.